Comparison11 min read
Headless Shopify vs a Shopify theme for a wine or spirits brand: which do you need?

The short answer
For many wine and spirits brands, a Shopify theme is the right choice: it is the least work to launch, your team edits everything in Shopify, and apps add to the pages without a developer. Headless Shopify keeps Shopify for products, checkout and orders, and replaces the theme with a custom-built website. Headless Shopify is worth its extra cost and upkeep when the shop has to look and move like the brand in ways a theme can't, or sit inside a larger website such as a wine estate's.
What a Shopify theme is, and what headless means
Shopify is the system that holds your products, stock, payments and orders. The two routes differ in what your customers see on top of it.
Either way you are on Shopify. The choice is where the pages come from, and what that costs to build and to keep running.
At Beyond we build most new online shops on headless Shopify, and we tell clients to stay on a theme whenever a theme does the job. Below is where each route wins, drawing on Shopify's own guidance as well as our studio's work.
A Shopify theme and headless Shopify side by side
| A Shopify theme | Headless Shopify | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the design comes from | A ready-made or custom Shopify theme | A custom website, designed and built for you |
| How far the look can go | As far as the theme and its code allow | As far as it can be designed and coded |
| Speed | Depends on the theme, the pictures and the apps installed | Depends on how well the pages are built and hosted |
| What your team edits | Everything in Shopify, with one login | Products and prices in Shopify, pages in a separate editor |
| Apps | Many add to the page from the theme editor | Each app that shows on the page has to be connected or replaced |
| Checkout | Shopify Checkout | Shopify Checkout |
| To build | The least work to launch | A design and development project |
| To keep running | Shopify hosts the pages | Someone has to host, update and fix the pages |
| The main risk | Looking like other shops on the same theme | Paying for, and depending on, more than you need |
How the two compare for a drinks brand
How far the shop can look and move like the brand
People buy a bottle for its story as much as its price: the vineyard, the distiller, the label. A good theme with good photographs can tell that story well. A developer can also change a theme's code, or build a theme from scratch, and Shopify itself says both routes allow a custom design.
Headless goes further when the pages have to do things a theme struggles with: film that fills the screen, artwork that moves as you scroll, or a shop that is one part of a bigger website, such as a wine estate's.
Speed
Headless is often sold as the faster route. It can be, but neither route is quick or slow by nature. Shopify's own comparison says a theme's speed depends on its code, its pictures and the apps installed, and a headless shop's on its code, its hosting and its pictures.
A Shopify theme
Quick: A light theme with well-sized photographs
Slow: A theme carrying a dozen apps and oversized pictures
Headless Shopify
Quick: A well-built custom site
Slow: A badly built custom site
If your shop is slow today, have someone check the pictures and the apps before you pay for a rebuild.
What your team can change themselves
Ask to see that editor, and have the person who will use it try adding a product page before you agree to anything.
Apps
Much of what a drinks shop adds later comes from Shopify's app store: reviews, a wine club or subscription, loyalty points. On a theme, many apps add their part to the page from the theme editor, with no developer needed.
On a headless shop the pages are not Shopify's, so an app that shows something to the customer has to be connected by a developer, or swapped for something else. Shopify's advice before going headless is to check how subscriptions, reviews, loyalty programmes and analytics will work. List every app you rely on, and ask what happens to each one.
What it takes to build and to keep running
A theme is the least work to launch, and Shopify hosts the pages for you.
A headless shop is a design and development project, and the work carries on after launch. Someone has to host the pages, keep the code up to date and fix what breaks. Shopify puts it this way: headless adds control, "along with responsibility for maintaining it". It also tells you to budget separately for development, for the system your team edits pages in, and for any hosting.
A custom shop also ties you to people who can work on its code. Find out who that will be in two years' time, and what happens if you part ways.
When a Shopify theme is the right choice
For many wine and spirits shops a theme is the right answer, and you don't need a studio like ours to launch one.
A theme is enough when
- it is your first shop, and you want to learn what sells before you spend more
- you have good photographs of the bottles and the place they come from
- the theme and the apps you use already do what your customers need
- your team wants to run everything from one login
Shopify's own reasons to keep a theme are much the same. It adds one more: a launch date or a budget that leaves little room for custom development.
If a shop on a theme is underperforming, the theme is often not the cause.
Sometimes better product photographs and better product descriptions are enough.
When headless Shopify is worth it
Headless earns its cost when the pages have work to do that a theme can't.
The usual signs
- the brand's look is one of the reasons people buy, and the shop has to carry film, illustration or animation and stay quick
- each wine or spirit needs a page that tells its own story, in a layout a theme doesn't offer
- the shop is one part of a larger website, such as a wine estate's or a distillery's
- you have people to look after the code after launch, or will pay for them
The last one matters as much as the other three.
A custom shop with nobody looking after it will serve you worse than a well-kept theme.
The route matters less than what you do after launch
A shop's sales come down to two numbers: how many people visit, and what share of them buy. Neither a theme nor a headless build moves those by itself. Plenty of people can design a handsome shop. The visitors come from search, ads and social media, and the share who buy rises when someone measures where they drop out and tests a better version.
Bring people in
Search, so people find you without a paid click. Ads for the searches worth paying for. Social media for the people who haven't searched yet.
Measure what they do
A website should be measured. We use PostHog to see where people arrive, where they give up, and how many go on to buy.
Test a change
An A/B test shows half your visitors one version of a page and half another. The numbers pick the winner, not opinions.
Keep what works
The winner stays and the next test starts, so the same number of visitors brings more orders.
Then round again, every month
Headless gives more room to test, because every page is yours to change. A theme can be tested too, within what the theme allows. Either way, budget for this work as well as the build.
Which route suits which drinks brand
A ready-made theme
- Suits
- A first shop, a small range or a close launch date, with good photographs and a team that wants one login.
- Not for
- A brand whose look is the reason people buy, or a shop that has to sit inside a bigger website.
A customised theme
- Suits
- A growing shop that wants a look of its own and still relies on Shopify's editor and its apps.
- Not for
- Pages built around film and animation that a theme can't carry.
Headless Shopify
- Suits
- An established wine or spirits brand whose shop has to look and move like the brand, with a budget for upkeep.
- Not for
- A first shop, a tight budget, or a team with nobody to call when the code needs attention.
Six questions to ask before you choose
Shopify suggests putting questions like these to any developer or agency before a headless build. Ask us them too.
What can't our theme do?
Name the thing. If nobody can name it, stay on the theme.
What happens to each app we use?
Ask which carry on, which need connecting and which need replacing.
Who edits what, and where?
Ask to try the editor your team would use.
What will we pay each month after launch?
Hosting, upkeep, apps and the editing system are all separate from Shopify's own plan.
Who owns the code, and who fixes it when it breaks?
Get both answers in writing.
Who will work on sales after launch?
Ask who brings visitors to the shop, who measures what they do, and whether anyone tests changes.
Selling alcohol online has its own rules, whichever route you take. Check them for every place you plan to ship to before the shop is designed.
How Beyond builds shops for drinks brands
Beyond is a seven-person studio in Southampton. We design and code shops, and make the photographs, film, illustration and packaging that go on them. New shops usually run on Shopify, with the pages your customers see designed and coded by us. Your team runs products and prices in Shopify, and the words and pictures in an editor we set up.
The brands, labels, films and websites we've made for drinks clients are on our pages for wine brands and spirit brands.
Headless is not right for every shop, and our ecommerce page says so. If a well-chosen theme already does what you need, it is the simpler route, and we'll tell you so on the first call. Everything else we make for drinks brands, from the label to the film, is planned with the shop it will appear on.
Questions
What is headless Shopify?
Headless Shopify is a way of building a Shopify shop where the pages customers browse are a separate, custom-built website. Shopify still holds the products, takes the payments and handles the orders, and customers still pay through Shopify Checkout. Because the pages aren't tied to a theme, they can be designed freely. Headless Shopify costs more to build than a theme, and someone has to look after the pages afterwards.
Is headless Shopify better than a Shopify theme?
No, not in general. Headless Shopify gives a designer and a developer more freedom, and gives you more to pay for and maintain. A Shopify theme is quicker to launch, keeps everything in one editor and lets many apps add to your pages without a developer. Headless is the better choice only when your shop needs something a theme can't do, and you can name what that is.
Is headless Shopify faster than a theme?
Not automatically. Shopify's own comparison says speed depends on the code, the hosting and the pictures on a headless shop, and on the theme code, the pictures and the installed apps on a theme. A well-built headless shop can carry film and animation and stay quick. A light theme with well-sized photographs is quick too. Check the pictures and apps on a slow shop before you rebuild it.
Do Shopify apps work on a headless shop?
Some do, and some need work. On a headless shop the pages aren't Shopify's, so an app that shows something to the customer, such as reviews or a subscription, has to be connected by a developer or replaced. Shopify advises checking how subscriptions, reviews, loyalty programmes and analytics will work before you commit. List every app you use and ask about each one.
Can a wine shop move from a Shopify theme to headless later?
Yes. Both routes run on Shopify, so starting on a theme doesn't close off headless later. Shopify itself suggests the first step: find something your theme can't do, then ask a developer to scope the build and its upkeep. If the addresses of your pages change in the move, make sure each old link is sent to its new page, so saved links and search results still work.
Do I need an agency to set up a Shopify shop for my wine or spirits?
No. Shopify is made so that a business can choose a theme, add its products and open a shop itself, and for a first shop that is often the right start. Help is worth paying for when the photographs, the product pages or the design are holding the shop back, or when the shop needs to be custom-built. Beyond does that work, and tells you on the first call if a theme will do.
Made by Beyond
Tell us about your shop.
Tell us what you sell and how you sell it now. We'll reply within one working day, set up a free call, and tell you which route we'd suggest for your shop, even when that's a theme.
What happens next
- 1You'll hear back from us within one working day.
- 2We'll set up a free, no-obligation call with the people who'd actually do the work. Everything is made in-house.
- 3You get a clear proposal with scope, timeline and cost, usually within a week of our call.



