Comparison12 min read
One studio or separate branding, web and SEO agencies: what changes?
The short answer
Hiring one studio for the brand, the website and the marketing means you explain your business once, the photography, design and build are planned together, and one team answers when two pieces don't fit. Hiring a separate specialist for each gives you more depth in each discipline and no reliance on a single supplier, but joining the work up becomes your job. One studio suits a restaurant, hotel or drinks brand changing several things at once. Separate specialists suit a very large or highly technical job in one discipline.
The four ways to get the work done
A restaurant, hotel or drinks brand that needs a brand, a website and marketing can get them in four ways. They differ in how many teams you deal with and who joins the work up.
The fourth is an in-house team: people on your own payroll, usually for the day-to-day marketing.
Many businesses end up with a mix. What you are really choosing is which parts sit together, and who is in charge of the joins.
What changes between one studio and separate agencies
Six things change. Some favour one studio and some favour specialists.
How many times you explain your business
With one studio you explain it once. With three agencies you give three briefings, and each hears a slightly different version. Anything you decide with one has to be passed on to the other two, usually by you.
That only helps if the people you brief are the people who do the work. At most agencies, the people who pitch aren't the people who build, so ask who will be in the room.
Who is answerable when two pieces don't fit
The trouble is usually at the joins.
- The new logo doesn't work small on a phone.
- The website launches without the pages the search plan needed.
- The photographs are all wide and the page needs upright ones.
With separate suppliers, each can fairly say their part was done as briefed, and sorting it out falls to you.
With one studio there is nobody else to point at.
Whether the photography, design and build are planned together
Separate suppliers usually work one after another: the brand, then the photographs, then the website, then the marketing. Each inherits what the last one made. One studio can plan them together, so the list of shots is written from the page designs, and the website is built with the search plan already in hand.
How deep each specialism goes
This is where specialists win. An agency that does only SEO, or only web builds, has more people working on that one discipline and sees more of its hard cases. A small studio covers each discipline with one or two people. For a very large or highly technical job in one discipline, that may not be enough.
What happens when one supplier is slow
What you lose if the choice is wrong
If one specialist disappoints, you change that one. If the single studio is the wrong fit, you lose your designer, your developer and your marketer on the same day.
So one studio deserves more checking before you sign. Look at work they have done across every part you need, and speak to a client who has been with them for years.
One studio, separate agencies and freelancers side by side
| One studio | Separate agencies | Freelancers | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Briefing | Once, to one team | Once for each agency | Once for each person |
| Who joins the work up | The studio | You, or one agency you put in charge | You |
| When two pieces don't fit | One team answers for all of it | Each answers for its own part | Each answers for their own part |
| Photography, design and build | Planned together | Usually one after another | Usually one after another |
| Depth in each discipline | A few people in each | A whole team in each | One person, often very good at one thing |
| If someone is slow | Every part waits | The next agency waits, and you chase | The next person waits, and you chase |
| If the fit is wrong | You replace everything at once | You replace one part | You replace one person |
When separate specialists are the better choice
Separate specialists are the better choice in three situations.
- One part of the job is very large or highly technical. Work that needs many people in one discipline at the same time belongs with an agency built around that discipline.
- You already have a supplier you trust for one part. If your photographer or your SEO agency is doing good work, keep them. A good studio will work alongside them, and should say so.
- You need a scale a small studio does not have. Many venues opening at once, or marketing in several countries and languages, is more than a handful of people can carry.
It also helps to have someone on your side who can brief the specialists and hold them to one plan.
Without that person, the joins are nobody's job.
When one studio is the better choice
One studio is the better choice when several things are changing at once and have to match: a new opening, a new look, or a relaunch where the website, the pictures and the way people find you are all in play. It also suits a business with nobody free to manage suppliers, because the managing is the part you hand over.
The Kirkmichael Arms, a pub in Ayrshire, was the same kind of job. Beyond drew the illustrations, spent three days photographing the food and the landscape around it, built the website and ran the SEO. Traffic rose 45% in the first three months, with the new website and the SEO work behind it.
Design is easy to buy. Results are the harder part
There are a lot of people who can design. What is harder to find is a team that designs the website, brings people to it, and then keeps improving what those people do once they arrive. With separate agencies that work crosses three companies: the SEO agency sees the visitors, the web agency owns the pages, and nobody owns the bookings in between. In one studio, the people who read the numbers are the people who can change the page.
Bring people in
Search, so people find you without a paid click. Ads for the searches worth paying for. Social media for the people who haven't searched yet.
Measure what they do
A website should be measured. We use PostHog to see where people arrive, where they give up, and how many go on to book.
Test a change
An A/B test shows half your visitors one version of a page and half another. The numbers pick the winner, not opinions.
Keep what works
The winner stays and the next test starts, so the same number of visitors brings more bookings.
Then round again, every month
Separate agencies can run this loop too, if someone on your side joins it up. Ask who that will be before you hire.
Where freelancers and an in-house team fit
Who each route suits
One studio
- Suits
- A restaurant, hotel or drinks brand changing its look, its website and its marketing together, with nobody free to manage several suppliers.
- Not for
- A very large or highly technical job in one discipline, or work at a scale beyond a small team.
Separate agencies
- Suits
- A business with a marketing team that can brief and coordinate suppliers, or one large job in a single discipline.
- Not for
- A project where the brand, the photographs and the website must fit together, with nobody on your side to join them up.
Freelancers
- Suits
- One contained job with a clear brief, and an owner or manager with the time to direct it.
- Not for
- Several linked jobs at once, or work that needs cover when one person is away.
Eight questions to ask any agency or studio before hiring
These apply whichever route you take. The answers tell you more than a list of services does.
Who does the work, and will I talk to them?
Ask for names, and whether the people in the first meeting are the people who design and build.
Which parts do you do yourselves, and which do you pass on?
Passing work to an outside supplier is common. You should know before you sign, not after.
Who is my contact, and who covers when they are away?
One named person is better than a shared inbox.
If two parts don't fit, who puts it right?
Ask for an example of when that happened and what they did.
What happens after launch?
Find out who fixes things, how you reach them, and what ongoing work costs each month.
What do I keep if we part ways?
The domain name, the website, the photographs, and the logins to your ad and analytics accounts should all be yours.
Can I hire you for one part only, and can I speak to a client?
A good agency or studio will say yes to both.
Who is answerable for results, not only for delivery?
Ask who brings people to the website, who measures what they do, and who changes the page when the numbers say so.
If the job is a website, our guide to what a restaurant website costs has seven more questions for comparing quotes.
How Beyond works, and where it doesn't fit
Beyond is the first route. We are a team of seven in Southampton: a creative director, a lead developer, an SEO specialist, two designers who also animate and edit video, a film director and a photographer. The same seven do the branding, the website design, the SEO and the photography and film, and nothing is passed to outside suppliers.
Your first call is with the people who would work on your project. Daniel, the creative director, runs every project and stays your main contact from start to finish. The team and how it started are on the About page.
Seven people is also a deliberate limit. We don't put ten people on an account, roll out fifty locations at once or run search in twelve languages. For a job of that scale, a large specialist agency is the better choice. You can hire us for one service or for all of them, and keep a supplier you already trust for the rest.
Clients tend to stay. Beyond has worked with The Fat Duck since 2016. Incognito has had its look from Beyond since its bars opened, then came back for the boxes and labels of its spirits range. For Fortunate Son, a winery in Napa Valley, Beyond drew and animated a character for each wine, built the website and ran the SEO.
Questions
Is it better to hire one agency or several?
One agency is better when the brand, the website and the marketing are changing together and need to match, because one team plans all of it and answers for all of it. Several are better when one part of the job is very large or highly technical, or when you already trust a supplier for one part. If you hire several, decide at the start who joins the work up. If nobody is named, it will be you.
Is a specialist SEO agency better than a studio that also does SEO?
For a very large website or a highly technical problem, usually yes: a specialist has more people working on search and nothing else. For a single restaurant, hotel or drinks brand, the bigger question is whether the SEO findings get built into the website, because a report is only useful once someone acts on it. Ask either kind of agency who does the SEO, by name, and who makes the changes to the site.
Can I use one studio for the brand and website and keep my SEO agency?
Yes. Ask the studio at the start, and a good one will be happy to work alongside a supplier you already trust. Agree who is responsible for what, and make sure your SEO agency sees the plans for the website before the build begins, not after launch. Beyond's clients hire it for one service or for all of them.
Should I hire freelancers instead of an agency?
Yes, if the job is contained and you have the time to direct it. A good freelance photographer or designer gives you one person's full attention. It gets harder when the work of several freelancers has to fit together, because joining it up is your job, and nobody covers when one of them is away. Ask each freelancer which parts they do themselves and which they pass on.
When should a restaurant or hotel hire an in-house marketer?
When there is marketing to do every day: social posts, emails to guests, menu and event updates, replies to reviews. Someone on the premises does that better than an outside team. Brand design, website builds, photography and film come in bursts, so they are usually bought in. The two work well together when the in-house person is the one contact for the studio or the agencies.
Who would I deal with if I hired Beyond?
Daniel, Beyond's creative director. He runs every project and is your main contact by email, phone and video call. Your first call is with the people who would work on your project, and the rest of the seven-person team join for the parts that need them. Nothing is passed to outside suppliers, so the person answering your question is someone who worked on it.
Made by Beyond
Tell us what you need made.
Tell us what you have and what you need, even roughly, and name any suppliers you want to keep. We'll reply within one working day and set up a free call with the people who'd do the work.
What happens next
- 1You'll hear back from us within one working day.
- 2We'll set up a free, no-obligation call with the people who'd actually do the work. Everything is made in-house.
- 3You get a clear proposal with scope, timeline and cost, usually within a week of our call.



